Wick vs Discord AutoMod vs Supervisor: three layers, not three choices

Bottom line: these are three layers rather than three choices. AutoMod is free and is the only one that blocks a message before it posts, Wick defends the structure of the server against nukes and raids, and Supervisor reads what legitimate members are saying. A large public server should run all three.

Most comparison posts end with a recommendation. This one ends with three, because these tools do not overlap enough to compete. Wick protects the structure of your server, Discord AutoMod blocks words before they post, and Supervisor reads what messages mean.

You can run all three at once, and for a large public server that is the correct answer rather than a hedge. What follows is what each one actually covers, so you can tell which layers you are missing.

The short answer

• You already have AutoMod. It is free, native, and the only one of the three that blocks a message before it is posted. Turn it on regardless of what else you run.
• Add Wick if your risk is structural: raids, nukes, rogue or compromised admins, alt-account floods.
• Add Supervisor if your risk is what legitimate members are saying to each other.

At a glance

Layer one: Discord AutoMod

Free, built in, available for all servers rather than Community servers only.

It gives you the Commonly Flagged Words Rule with three ready-made categories, Insults and Slurs, Sexual Content and Severe Profanity, plus a Custom Keywords Rule where you write your own, capped at six keyword rules per server, each holding up to 1,000 keywords and 10 regex patterns. On the spam side there is a Block Spam Content Rule and a Block Mention Spam Rule with a limit up to 50 mentions per message and optional mention raid detection.

Its unique property is that it blocks before the message is posted. No bot can do this. A bot sees a message after it has appeared and then deletes it, which always leaves a window where members can read it. If the requirement is that a specific word never reaches the channel, AutoMod is the correct and only tool.

Its documented limits: three built-in categories, six keyword rules, and Discord's own statement that "the word lists of Commonly Flagged Words, as well as the Spam Content filter, are currently only available in English". No documented image or video filter, and every rule judges one message alone.

Layer two: Wick

Wick's own documentation calls anti-nuke "the critical feature that differentiates Wick from all other Discord Bots", and it is aimed at a completely different threat model to the other two: not the ordinary member, but the person who already has permissions.

Anti-nuke monitors channel and role creation and deletion, bans and kicks, and webhook creation and deletion. Attempts to bypass quarantine, to add dangerous permissions to any role, or to change the vanity URL trigger quarantine themselves.

Panic mode locks the server down on detecting a nuke, hands authority to the owner and Wick, and deploys a separate isolated "miniWick" to retrieve pre-attack state so the main bot is not overloaded.

The restore system reloads the latest backup and reverts deletions made during the attack. Wick is candid that without Imaging enabled this "is a finicky process and lacks a lot of information and the server may not be restored properly".

Verification and quarantine control who gets in and strip power from suspected bad actors.

Its automod is the Heat system, where every action adds heat that decays over time rather than tripping a fixed threshold. Heat comes from message repetition, emojis, characters, new lines, mentions with @everyone weighted heavily, attachments, inactivity in quiet channels, blacklisted words and links, advertisement, NSFW websites and malicious websites including IP-grabbers and keyloggers.

Its limit is that heat measures behaviour, not content. A single calm, correctly spelled message sent at a normal pace generates almost no heat regardless of what it says.

Layer three: Supervisor

This is ours, so weigh it accordingly.

Supervisor moderates with AI models that read what a message means rather than matching strings or measuring rate. It classifies across 16 labels including harassment, hate, threats, insults, scams, spam, sexual content, self-harm, violence and illegal activity. It weighs recent conversation history when a message is ambiguous on its own, has implicit moderation for harm that is implied rather than stated, moderates images and video by reading content, and works in over 100 languages without a word list per language. £13.99 a month, or about £4.99 on the three year cycle, billed per account so one subscription covers every server.

Its limits against the other two are substantial. It deletes after a message posts rather than blocking before, so it does not replace AutoMod. It has no anti-nuke, no anti-raid, no panic mode, no backups, no restore, no quarantine and no verification, so it does not replace Wick. Its actions are Delete, Timeout and Warn, so it cannot ban or kick, where AutoMod can block a member's interactions entirely and Wick can ban.

Where the layers do not overlap

The useful way to see this is by asking what each one misses that another catches.

A slur typed in plain English. AutoMod blocks it before it posts. Wick's blacklist may add heat. Supervisor would catch it but only after posting. AutoMod wins.

A raid of fifty accounts created yesterday. AutoMod has mention raid detection. Wick has panic mode, verification and account age filtering. Supervisor has nothing. Wick wins.

An admin deleting every channel. Only Wick sees it at all.

A calmly written threat to one member, correctly spelled, no listed words. AutoMod matches no keyword and has no threat category. Wick's heat barely moves. Supervisor is the only one that reads it.

A scam in Portuguese. AutoMod's presets are English only. Wick's blacklists are what you wrote. Supervisor works across over 100 languages. Supervisor wins.

Harm posted as an image. Neither AutoMod nor Wick documents reading image content. Supervisor is the only one.

A member spelling around your filters with fr33 n1tr0 or h a t e. Both lists miss it. Supervisor reads the intent.

So which should you use?

Every server: AutoMod, on, configured. It costs nothing and it is the only thing that stops a message appearing at all.

Large public servers, or any server where a moderator account being compromised would be a disaster: add Wick. Nothing else in this comparison protects the structure of the server, and no amount of content moderation helps once someone starts deleting channels.

Servers where the members are legitimate and the problem is what they post: add an AI layer. That is the gap neither of the other two is designed to fill, and it is the one that produces the harassment reports your moderators are actually handling.

Budget order if you cannot do all three: AutoMod first because it is free. Then whichever of your two remaining risks is real, which is a question about your server rather than about the tools. If you have never been raided but your mod team spends its time on harassment reports, the content layer matters more. If you run a large server with many staff roles, the security layer does.

The detail on each pairing is in Supervisor vs Discord AutoMod and Supervisor vs Wick, and there is a piece on whether AutoMod alone is enough.

Why trust this comparison

Everything above comes from the vendors' own material: Discord's auto moderation developer documentation and its AutoMod FAQ, last updated 15 June 2026, and Wick's features page and command reference on docs.wickbot.com. All read on 29 August 2026. Wick's public rating on top.gg was 84 out of 100 from 259 ratings that day, on top.gg's 0 to 100 scale.

We make Supervisor, so this is not a neutral comparison and we have not written it as one. What we have done instead is put the other side's advantages in their own section above, in plain terms, and say where we could not read something rather than guessing at it.

On our own side, the figures come from our source and our evaluation set rather than from marketing copy. Supervisor's models are retrained on real moderation feedback, the thumbs up and thumbs down votes people leave on live flags in their own servers, which is the closest thing to customer research this category has. The last full retrain moved average F1 across the 16 labels from 0.794 to 0.941 on our internal evaluation set, with errors on harmless messages down 44 percent, and version 2.2 improved macro-F1 again across all three model tiers. The method and the per-label numbers are in the 2.1 release post.

Where Supervisor leads, and where it does not. On moderation coverage specifically it is the most complete tool in this series: 16 labels where nothing else classifies more than four, over 100 languages, conversation context, and the only one that reads images and video. It is also the narrowest, with no bans, no raid protection and no utility features, which is why every post here recommends running it alongside another bot rather than instead of one.

We have no customer reviews, ratings or testimonials to show you, because we have not collected any. Judge it on your own content in the live demo rather than on our word for it.

For developers and platforms

AutoMod is a Discord feature and Wick is a Discord bot, so neither exists outside Discord. If you are moderating your own product, Supervisor has a REST API with SDKs for Python, JavaScript, Go, Rust and Java, plus a Platform API for provisioning moderation to your own users. The API reference has the endpoints and rates.

The quickest way to find which layer you are missing is to take a message your current setup let through and paste it into the live demo, or add Supervisor to your server.